The Five-Point Scale
The Five-Point Scale
I first created the 3-point scale to be a simple no-fuss method of rating things to based on it's own merits. Recently, a few friends and I have created the Whiskey Adventurers Guild (WAG). A group of like-minded people who enjoy whiskey and want to try more. At a meeting in March, I pitched the idea of using the 3-point scale to rate the different whiskeys we tried. The Guild felt that the 3-point system is limiting, and doesn't provide enough nuance. After many discussions and contemplation, I humbly present a NEW system, the 5-Point Scale.
The 5-Point Scale offers several improvements. Mostly around how you would purchase and consume the beverage.
As I go into how the scale works, I'll be using whiskey as example.
The 5-Point Scale
| Rating | Explanation |
|---|---|
| 1 | I wouldn't drink it, even if you bought it. |
| 2 | I would drink it was the only option. |
| 3 | I would buy and drink this. |
| 4 | I prefer to drink this. |
| 5 | I hoard this and guard access to it. |
Diving deeper
1 Rating
This is something that I actively avoid as much as I can. I will never consume
In Whiskey Terms: I would not drink this whiskey under any circumstances.
2 Rating
This is something I probably have from some event we hosted, or it was a gift. I don't want to drink it, but it's there.
In Whiskey Terms: I would consume this drink if it was the ONLY option.
3 Rating
Always a safe and solid option. I will buy this for myself, but it's nothing overly impressive.
In Whiskey Terms: I do buy this, and it serves as the "well" option at my home. Examples include Bulleit, Old Grand-dad, Wild Turkey.
4 Rating
This is my premium option. It's a bit nicer, I probably save it for more special occasions or when I want to impress with a cocktail.
In Whiskey Terms: I do buy this, and it serves as a "premium" option at my home. Examples include Fancier Bulleit, Basil Hayden, Stateline Gin
5 Rating
This is one of the best liquors I've ever had the pleasure to consume. I'm buying and hiding it. I share it on the rarest of occasions.
In Whiskey Terms: This is a real treat. I love it, so I hide it away. Examples include Shieldaig 18, Stateline Distillery's Whiskey
Why?
I'm pleased with this. Hopefully my friends like it too. I'll find out soon. As I was writing this, I tapped into how I internally classify my drinks. It also made me realize I should have a special place to store my 5-rated beverages.